Showing posts with label Identity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Identity. Show all posts

Thursday, 3 July 2014

The Impotence of Words

It is intriguing that the noble Daniel Klein is pursuing a quest to reclaim the original, anti- rather than pro-government, use of the word "liberal", but he annoys me when he says, in an interview, that the word is "powerful". What evidence is there for this proposition? It is used in the original sense, or in a sense somewhat close to the original one, in countries like France and Sweden, whereas in the US it has, of course, acquired in many ways the opposite meaning. To define "liberal" as pro-welfare state is profoundly illogical to me and I wish Klein luck in his endeavour, but since France and Sweden are arguably quite a bit less liberal (in the classical sense) than the US, why would Klein claim the word is "powerful"? It has not made its original users more market orientated.

Casual evidence from other contexts suggests to me that words mean very little, indeed. In some countries, such as Finland and Iran, the dominant language does not distinguish between the sexes in its pronouns. H. L. Mencken's wonderful The American Language tells me (in a footnote on p. 175) that the third-person pronoun hesh was suggested in America around a hundred years ago to mean "he or she" in everyday usage. It evidently never took off, but that is how Finnish and Farsi work. So one way of estimating the effect of words on society is to look at how the gender-neutrality of pronouns might result in differences in how men and women behave in these countries compared to comparable ones. If language impacts how one views the world - as claimed by the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis - men and women speaking Farsi and Finnish should behave differently than those speaking, say, English or French.

I strongly doubt the differences are significant here, if they exist at all; for instance, while women make up a high 40 per cent of the members of the Finnish parliament, the corresponding figure for Sweden is almost 45 per cent. Wikigender reports that the share of female members of corporate boards is also lower in Finland than it is in Sweden. Now there are certainly also studies indicating that gendered pronouns do influence how people think. However, to the best of my knowledge, the studies which support the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis are of the variety that they ask subjects to read a text in which the gendered pronoun is prominent, then ask about career prospects, alternatively ask whether a man or a woman comes to mind.

Frankly, I cannot see why anyone would take these things too seriously. They offer some evidence, but it is very weak. If the image of a man, rather than that of a woman, comes to mind when using the pronoun "he" generically, and this has lasting consequences for one's attitudes or career choices or anything else of actual substance, then I believe one is so deficient in ability to reflect and make important life decisions that one simply does not exist; I cannot believe any human is that stupid. I hasten to add that this is far from my field and readers familiar with more evidence than this are welcome to contribute in the comments.

There are, of course, some studies in economics which look at attitudes and language. Guido Tabellini has claimed that usage of the second-person singular pronoun, rather than the plural, to address others, as well as capitalization of the word "I", are related to levels of respect, and a recent article in the Journal of Law and Economics links gendered pronouns to lower levels of maternity leave, but it seems to be sensitive to the inclusion or absence of just one or two countries, and neither of these articles includes - as far as I can recall - very many countries.

Some words begin to take on a pejorative meaning, such as nigger, cracker, kike and red-skin. Those may be powerful (although whether decent folks should avoid them is another issue - their using them might conceivably destroy their evil power?), but in these cases other words take on the original meaning of the pejoratives, so that what is really meant can still be expressed. I like the word liberal in its original sense and wish Klein and associates every bit of luck as I tend to use liberal to mean "small government". However, I would like to see some good evidence that the word is really as powerful as Klein claimed.
 
HT: Econlog's David R. Henderson

Monday, 7 April 2014

Women Earn Less than Half of Their Household's Income, But Why?

Last year (this bears bringing up even though it is not really recent), I attended an unusually rewarding workshop at the University of Chicago (this is saying a great deal, for almost every workshop is a veritable party in one's mind that never stops - well, at least not until the discussions are over...). This one was given by Professor Marianne Bertrand of the Booth School of Business and the topic was male-female relative earnings in married couples. In a working paper with Emir Kamenica and Jessica Pan, Bertrand displays the stunning pattern in marriages that women rather consistently contribute less than half of the household's market income. It looks as if there is widespread aversion to the woman's earning more than does the man within the household. I will offer much praise and one piece of constructive criticism on the thesis, but I start with the praise. The graph is beautiful (click to enlarge):
Households in which the wife earns more than does the husband seem to form much less frequently than do households in which the husband earns more. The discontinuity above is larger for less educated couples. Bertrand and her coauthors also document a tendency for divorce to occur more frequently in couples in which the woman earns more than fifty per cent of household income. Bertrand and her coauthors argue that this is due to a version of identity economics (made famous, most prominently, by research by George Akerlof and Rachel Kranton), saying that there is a problem in case the wife earns more than does the husband.

I really enjoyed this paper, which is all the more important considering that women are increasingly acquiring all that is needed to out-earn men (I am thinking specifically of college graduation rates, in field after field).

Now for my piece of constructive criticism. The focus in the paper is wholly on how norms shape male-female relative income within households, but not mentioned is an alternative interpretation of the data based on socio-biology. It goes as follows: Men have more to lose than have women if their spouse is unfaithful. This is standard evolutionary biology (or at least it is my impression of what is considered standard evolutionary biology). If a man is unfaithful, his wife will not spend scarce resources raising some other woman's child. But if a woman is unfaithful, her husband ends up caring for someone else's genetic material.

This means that a husband has particularly strong reasons to look for an effective punishment mechanism so that the wife will be disincentivized to cuckold him. Supposing husband and wife have equal shares in household income, the punishment is greater if the woman's contribution to it was less than half. This also means that women occasionally have incentives to commit to earning less, say by spending less time working and consequently acquiring less human capital (such as experience and on-the-job training), in order to attract a husband.

My explanation is a bit akin to the theory of efficiency wages, according to which workers receive greater compensation than their productivity would indicate in order to instill fear in them not to shirk on the job, since wages higher than marginal product imply a risk of involuntary unemployment. Analogously, if women receive a share of household income greater than the share they contribute, they will be less likely to commit adultery ("shirk"), since there would be more to lose.

However, the socio-biological explanation has no counterpart to involuntary unemployment. The woman could then simply re-marry. However, since initially the man earned more than half of household income, the probability of the wife's finding a man of similar income to her first husband is not as great as it would be if male-female incomes had initially been the same.

I don't believe anybody actually chooses their partner based on explicit thinking along my suggested lines, but evolutionary biology merely gives us certain preferences, not necessarily ready perception of them or the ability to rationalize them.